Marikana: South Africa police 'lied over mine shootings'

Miners marched past the Lonmin mine to mark the anniversary of the shootings

 

South African police lied about the Marikana shootings last year, in which 34 striking miners were killed, a commission of inquiry has said.

Police falsified or withheld documents, and gave false accounts of events, it said.
Police spokesman Solomon Makgale said the statement was "unfortunate and highly prejudicial".
The police shooting of the miners at the Lonmin-owned platinum mine in August 2012 shocked the nation.
The police said they were acting in self-defence, days after two officers had been hacked to death by protesters.

---

This is a searing attack on the credibility of South Africa's police.

At issue right now, is not so much what happened at Marikana on 16 August last year, as the way the police have presented their version of events to the inquiry.

To put it crudely - as with former US President Nixon's Watergate scandal - it is not the crime, it's the cover-up.

It is some 10 days now since a senior policeman giving evidence to the inquiry, Lt Col Duncan Scott - discussing evidence that he'd brought in on his own computer hard drive - almost casually agreed to hand it over to the commission's lawyers.

It quickly became clear that the hard drive contained potentially explosive material, and the inquiry was promptly postponed, as analysts pored over the files and compared them with the police's detailed description of what led to the shooting dead of 34 miners.

That analysis work is not complete, but the commission is clearly so outraged by what has already been uncovered that it has taken the extraordinary step of calling the police liars and forgers, and implicitly questioning whether the Marikana inquiry - beset by delays and funding controversies - can continue.

The commission was appointed by President Jacob Zuma to investigate the deaths of the 34 miners - the most deadly police action since the end of white minority rule in 1994.

At issue right now, is not so much what happened at Marikana last year, as the way the police have presented their version of events to the inquiry, says BBC Africa correspondent Andrew Harding.
To put it crudely - as with former US President Nixon's Watergate scandal - it's not the crime, it's the cover-up, our correspondent says.
The commission's statement comes just 10 days after gaining access to police computer hard drives and previously unseen police documents.
"We have obtained documents which the SAPS [South African Police Services] previously said were not in existence...
"We have obtained documents which in our opinion demonstrate that the [police] version of the events at Marikana... is in material respects not the truth," the commission said.
It said the material which had come to light had "serious consequences" for its future work.
The hearing was adjourned until Wednesday, while the commission reviewed the "thousands of pages" of documents, and sought to obtain access to additional hard drives and electronic records.
Our correspondent says that the commission is clearly so outraged by what has already been uncovered that it has taken the extraordinary step of calling the police liars and forgers, and implicitly questioning whether the Marikana inquiry - beset by delays and funding controversies - can continue.
The police spokesman said the commission had passed judgment without giving the police a chance to explain.
The inquiry has been delayed several times over the question of who should pay the legal fees for hundreds of injured and arrested miners. The new information may jeopardise its October deadline.
Demonstrations were held in Pretoria last week over the government's refusal to pay legal fees for miners appearing at the inquiry.

How the Marikana shooting was reported at the time

In the immediate aftermath of the police killings, the authorities sought to portray the miners, who were striking illegally, as responsible for the bloodshed.
Some 270 of the striking miners were arrested and charged with murder, though the charges were later provisionally dropped.
The government has been criticised for its handling of the crisis, and some of the Marikana miners remain angry that not a single policeman has yet been arrested over the shootings.